[void] - Great shapes and render, but as mentioned before, felt it lacked an ability to maintain anything.
ScaryPotato - Liking the retro feel. As above, not sure how he could maintain anything with pincer hands.
Daveneale - Highly original design, i liked it very much. Just a feel of the top appendage not being needed. (IMO of course).
Spitch - Loverly render, but it reminded me too much of those 80's drink serving robots.
D-Holme - Very 'star wars -esque' droid design (a very good thing in my book). Feel the render lets it down somewhat... very muddy colours. Leg anatomy looks a bit off as well.
RhandAlThor - My favorite part is the head.. well rendered and designed. The rest of the droid looks a bit off though, especially the far leg which seems broken.
hallo - Love the cube idea, easily stakable, practical, realistic. Nice render, but feel it looks limited to only being able to do a bit of soldering... maybe that's the idea?
brian h - I have been trying to judge this based on a droid that 'could' exist. For me I think yours fits that best. A power source, many maintenance parts, robust, simple shapes. The CAT colour sceme really suited it to... you got my vote.
ATAnderson - As has been said before, good job with the welding. The driod felt a bit front heavy, nice colours, limited fix-it options.
Kreator - Very steampunk. Liked it a lot. Patricularly the coal fired chest, very well captured. Kept from the win for me for a lack of practicality, just couldnt see a company making them.
collinsully - Really like your colour sceme, and the little details like the colour change on the edges of the glass pane, and the suction cups. It was just too limited in its movement from the shape we could see to be an effective droid.
Hideyoshi - Great drawing, colour sceme, and render. A believable droid, just not for maintenance, imo.
Legato - Well done for the colour at the end. Gotta love the squid inspiration. Really believable droid, bit too simple colourations... glad you got the 'flitty' nature of my design, you pretty much descibed exactly what i had in my headwhen i came up with it!
baby-bel - Cute idea but cant see the practical side.
form2function - Like the simlicity of design, good colours, doesnt seem to be any area for the 'hover' gear though.
Zutaiola - As has been said you have done an awesome render. He looks like he has all the possible jobs covered. Feel his cutsiness takes away from practicalities, he reminds me of Jonny5 from the short ciciut films.
Muleskinner - An unusual take, cant quite decide what i think... doesnt seem like it could move very well, but if it had a conveyor belt going underneath could be convincing. Nice and original though.
yoitisi - Really like your style of line and colour, and the centaur is very original. The reason you didnt get my vote was the belivable factor. In another world, maybe, in the future of ours, probably not.
Adi - Beautiful render, and she would make a great cyborg. Just dont get a maintenance/repair feel from the design.
Well there's my opinions, i honestly hope to offend no-one and only offer constructive criticism. Thanks to all those who have taken the time to offer my design the benefit or their opinion.
Always strive for perfection. You will never achieve it, but will learn so much more in the striving.