As to the "threat" upon Matt and Trey's life... It really didn't sound like a threat to me. It honestly did sound like a warning. Saying something like "Hey, if you put on a blindfold and walk back and forth across a busy freeway you are going to get hit by a car" does not mean "I am going to hit you with my car."
For those who have not seen the "Threat" here is a copy.
"We have to warn Matt and Trey that what they are doing is stupid and they will probably wind up like Theo Van Gogh for airing this show. This is not a threat, but a warning of what will likely happen to them."
I am not Muslim... I am not Arabic... I am Irish and I would have to say I completely agree with the above statement. It sounds like an informed and objective observation as to the perceived consequences of Matt and Trey's actions. Regarding posting their addresses... it is a forum. Notice how no one ever said that the original poster of the message gave out their addresses? Can you control what other people write in your forum topics?
My main point going against this act was not to trash freedom of speech... but to say that I was tired of people using freedom of speech as a justification to be morally awful people. Our ancestors won our freedom (kinda). Are we going to use that freedom to be pricks?
On a side note, I keep hearing people say that you don't hear Buddhists or Christians giving death threats to Matt and Trey about depicting their Deities and to that... are you kidding me? Christians have been sending death threats to Matt and Trey for over a decade now. Muslims are just the currently popular rallying target.