hi, first time visiting your sketchbook. some people's sketchbooks on here are ridiculously long, but you dont have 1 zillion pages so i had time to look at all your work. im not sure what the time frame is like but you've definetly improved! the charcoal sketch of your boyfriend is very nice, and another one that caught my eye was your dragon/man character pencil sketch. You seem to continue growing in your understanding of value (your apples are very nice in that regard!). Some nice digital stuff too.
Unfortunately, I cant think of much off the top of my head critique wise that hasn't been forementioned. keep updating!