Results 1 to 13 of 18
Thread: the ambush
September 15th, 2006 #1
Hi Guys !
Did another Drow artwork beside my job. I'd appriciate cc for this thing, time: 1h 30 mins. ...
Hide this ad by registering as a memberSeptember 15th, 2006 #2Registered User
- Join Date
- Aug 2005
- Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
It looks cool, but in my opinion it's very rigid.
The elf's body is very vertical and the armoured lad is horizontal, also the drip stone makes the backdrop vertical, so the composition very square.
Maybe you should try make the tilted things such as the leg and arm follow parallel to the diagonals.
Maybe it's just me, I'm not too good at composition myself.
Also the elf seems to be pushing himself away from the man, if he was towering his victim he'd appear more threatening.
September 15th, 2006 #3
I really like it a lot.
To me, it's brilliant! The pose seems good to me. That bow would take a wide stance to use properly and i think its believeable. My only complaint is that my eyes keep moving towards that ball of light near the top left, please sort that out!
It would be great to see this finished
September 15th, 2006 #4
A few more highlights on the elf and bow would bring it out a little more. Not too many though for it would ruin the atmostshere of the piece (which is very good by the way) Though as said before the ball of light is a little too stark and could do with toning down abit
September 15th, 2006 #5
i'd add some more colors (light yellow, dark+grayish magenta),
move the light thing a bit to the right and maybe some lower,
add green light and blue shadow to the elf and green light to the knight,
add gray (+magenta) shadows on the uppest thing,
add more facial expression to the elf,
leave the hair luminous, but still add some more shadow to it
and draw the bow a bit further.(string)
It looks very nice, but unfinished.
the gras is always greener on my side
September 15th, 2006 #6
the hair kinda kills the mood in my opinion.
September 16th, 2006 #7
September 16th, 2006 #8
yes i like it very much, i dont see any problem with the comp.
September 16th, 2006 #9
Very cool! God I love this website, it's like taking a stroll through an art gallery in the comforts of my own home.
My only crit is, I really want to focus on the action in the scene--on the knight and the elf--but my eyes can't help going to the hair. It attracts a little too much attention to the point where my focus isn't where I want it to be. I LIKE the white hair, but I think it could be toned down a little (or the rest of the scene brought up a little) so it's less distracting from the composition as a whole.
WomenGamers.Com - Because Women DO Play
September 16th, 2006 #10
September 16th, 2006 #11
I find the composition very dynamic, though they all seem to be in the same plane, which tends to flatten things (ie. both characters are the exact same distance from viewer).
As for the characters, with the Drow, I really do love it. The hair is done in a way that suggest a face and obviously an elf/drow, and it's very slender. The legs are well done, but they probably both wouldn't be extended completely (for example, atleast one knee is typically bent a little or else the pose would be incredibly uncomfortable). Plus, after she was finished with her shot, it would be really hard to lift one leg without falling over
For the light: the Knight should be less detailed (less light on him) or the Drow should be lit from the front also--else the lighting is a little inconsistant.
[EDIT] also, the loin cloth should be far more detailed...i think it really flattens the Drow, and also I'd like to see the sword's scabberd behind the Drow, indicated by the hilt (it would give the piece more diagonals and detail)
September 16th, 2006 #12Registered User
- Join Date
- Aug 2006
- Rhode Island, USA
- Thanked 3 Times in 1 Post
Why would you have the action move from right to left? this is generally considered to create awkwardness and discomfort which isnt helped by the archers seemingly uncomfortable pose. the bow stance doesnt make any sense, and is much too wide, and the elf has a left-handed, which is very strange and uncommon in archery. the bow is also in front of the legs, which is uncomfortable and awkward to fire. also, whats the point in having the knife on his hip if he isnt going to use it? besides the fact that he could easily kill him with the knife in what could actually be a much more dramatic picture, theres a term that archers have for firing at close range, it's called "breaking an arrow"
criticisms aside, i like the lighting and colors of this piece. i think if you tucked the bow behind the leg, made the legs less foolishly wide, and flipped the entire thing horizontally to get better compositional movement and give the elf a right-handed bow, the peice would look much better
quick paintover to illustrate suggestion, though obviously a lot more would need to be reworked, since you cant fire the bow over your leg like that, yould need to hold the bow diagonally in the old yeoman style instead of tournament style and the leg still is in the way too much:
Last edited by Adarias; September 16th, 2006 at 03:57 PM.
September 16th, 2006 #13