Has anybody seen the Dredd trailer? I am torn as to rather I want to see the movie or not. I am excited for a new judge dredd more faithful to the comics, but I don't like the re-imagined world they created.
Things I like....
It looks like the movie has great atmosphere to it.
The action is cool
Dredd doesn't take his helmet off!
Some gripes so far....
Why are they using vehicles from the 90s? It set hundreds of years in the future.
The buildings shown so far don't scream out mega City, I guess I was hoping for a more "Coruscant" vibe to the city. The whole design is bland looking.
The story presented is eerily similar to the movie The Raid: Redemption (even though Dredd's story should have been locked down long before Raid went into production)
I just watched the trailer and gotta say. It looks seriously naff.
Things I like:
Dredd looks badass
Things I don't like:
Mega City one does not look like Mega City One. Surely the producers at least GLANCED at the original comics?!
The VFX are cheap. Seriously, sticking a bunch of identical skyscrapers on top of an image of an American city and copy pastaing it around is not fun. Also, what's with the lame dynamic FX like smoke?
The setting is as average as it can be. Take Dredd out and it may as well be Children of Men. The poor judges stand out like sore thumbs.
The fact that Dredd got taken out of Mega City One and flung into a completely different setting is kinnda of a deal breaker for me.
Looking forward on hearing other peeps' thoughts on this!
A smooth sea never made a skillful sailor.
Human beings, who are almost unique in having the ability to learn from the experience of others, are also remarkable for their apparent disinclination to do so."
I guess fucking it up once by misunderstanding the concept isn't enough. Isn't the comic meant to be a dark comedy with irresponsible social commentary and premium gore. Dredd's creators even call him fascist. His costume is designed in reference to the Franco regime. Can't they get somebody like Lloyd Kaufman or anybody that gets the joke to adapt the film. I think it would do as well as Machete or Inglorious Basterds if they went full retard. But I'm guessing this is going to be the next John Carter.
Last edited by Raoul Duke; June 27th, 2012 at 05:40 PM.
At least it doesn't have Rob Schneider in it. That has to count for something, right?
I watched the old Judge Dredd movie a month or so ago, it was one of my favourite films as a kid and it kinda held up to my memory (if you forgive the really cheesy acting and stuck on fx) but yeah..this trailer doesn't seem that bad.
I agree the design of Megacity isn't really that imaginative but it's more realistic than most of the way-out-there designs you get in sci-fi, when you consider it's supposed to be a dystopian future where there isn't going to be the money or the manpower to develop a magnificent city like the original, it's more likely going to be boring square high-rises I know this is supposed to be set way in the future and it's a fantasy sci-fi but we've had so many of them it's nice to see something a bit more gritty and realistic for a change.
tl:dr - I quite like the look of it
Last edited by Angel Intheuk; July 2nd, 2012 at 11:02 AM.
I'm also actually looking forward to it.
Would prefer it without the tacked on 3d though.
Getting tired of characters with pseudo Clint Eastwood voice though.
Mean Machine was done well, the angel gang should have been the
main antagonists. Rico is a very forgettable villain in the comics as well.
Great cast, Max von Sydow (one of my all time favourite actors) and
Jürgen Prochnow, another fantastic actor and I've always thought
Assante was underrated. Great sets, costumes, effects (Hammerstein!)...
Unfortunately I think a lot of mid-90s cinema was hit and miss. With
adaptions being real big misses.
For me, the most unforgivable sin was Stallone removing his helmet. I'm
a big 2000AD fan, but you don't even have to be to know that Dredd NEVER
takes off his helmet. But Sly could not wait to get it off fast enough.
And as mentioned, Schneider.
Interesting, a female villain. Is she the type that can carry her own and is a very smart leader? I love villains that look like they can hold their own and can command a posse, like Magneto (in later comics).
You have villains that surround themselves with people, but wonder how the hell they got top position, and someone could just off them at anytime because they're annoying.
So I wondering how this plays out.
From what I've seen in the trailer, she looks pretty bad-ass.
And not a stereotypical hot in leathers bad girl, just one dangerous lady.
I haven't ever seen a Judge Dredd comic.
I saw the old movie, when I was a kid and thought that that was great, and even got my hands on the video game because my dad was a fan.That said, I'm not so worried about it failing as a Judge Dredd movie (If I'm actually going to fork up the cash to see it). It is way more about Paul Verhoeven for me.
Without him, I just see this turning out into another $12 and 2 so hours of a huge crew and lots of money trying to convince us of: "This guy, this guy is BAD-ASS, no, no you have NO IDEA, just watch! see? SEE! THAT WAS BAD ASS! Oh! and Look at that! What did we tell you!?"I'm sorry, but I'm gonna continue here. I'm not gonna say that the old movie was a intellectual masterpiece, but at least it touched on some broader topics that let you enjoy a speculative look into human nature.
The story covered a great deal of distance for an hour and a half that left the viewer far away from were they begin.
I found the villain compelling, and his vengeance more believable by his role as both Dredd's old friend, foil, and symbol of the worst that can be brought from in a person. On the verge of multiplying out of control. =shiver=.
Compelling, entertaining, and didn't take itself too seriously.
I'm comparing that with a movie that can hardly make it through its two minute long trailer without showing us, what seems like the entirety of the plot. The villain? A drug empowered 2d character who manufactures jobs for the special effects department AKA "Slow-mo".................. I honestly wonder if it is supposed to be satire. What are the chances that the villains ability to control such a large group of people are ever going to be developed beyond the obvious? I'm not hopeful.
...The three "heroes" fend for their lives while delivering one liners that practically sound like someone with a bad need for male affirmation or penis envy wrote them.
Edit* But I gotta say, with some of these trailers that I'm watching, it really looks to me like some of these more recent, maybe a little unexperienced, newcomers are working their way onto the bigger in bigger ways. So, here is to seeing what they are gonna do with a handful of Freddie Wong videos for inspiration and years of film school under their belt... least I feel like that is what were getting...
...I forgot what I was talking about....
Last edited by Koudee; July 12th, 2012 at 10:57 AM. Reason: To many spaces.
Looking for mentor.
**Finished Work Thread **Process Thread **Edges Tutorial
Crash Course for Artists, Illustrators, and Cartoonists, NYC, the 2013 Edition!
"Work is more fun than fun."
"Art is supposed to punch you in the brain, and it's supposed to stay punched."
Ha ha ha ha
Turbocop VS Barristerbot is the one to wait for
I'm bummed they're remaking Robocop. From the art I've seen it's looking like Iron Man vs Megatron to me. I was hoping for some retro look at least.
That's all I want to see out of a remake. Retro designs that are pretty much the same as the original only made to not look like a guy in bulky plastic armor. Looks like they're keeping a similar satire with the writing though.
"Astronomy offers an aesthetic indulgence not duplicated in any other field. This is not an academic or hypothetical attraction and should require no apologies, for the beauty to be found in the skies has been universally appreciated for unrecorded centuries."
ED-209 was absolutely sinister in the original, even more so because of the stop motion animation. When it does its whole, "You have twenty seconds to comply," line, you know it isn't screwing about.
This new design looks too much like a Transformer or something, and given the high budget attached to the reboot, I don't think it will be suffering very many ultra-violent malfunctions.
Edit: I'm actually pretty excited for the new Dredd movie and I look forward to seeing it. I think reboots can be kind of good when the previous incarnations never live up to expectations. Sometimes good ideas and concepts get trashed by bad execution, but I don't think you can say that about Robocop, though.
Last edited by zx52hg; July 14th, 2012 at 04:51 PM.
Looks like my age is showing....
I'm uh, watching Robocop now...Still kinda disappointed at the trailer for J.D, but....This movie is pretty great.
Looking for mentor.
That Robocop remake is going to suck the sweat off a dead mans balls.