I saw the movie the other week and was underwhelmed. it looked good and had a great feel, it was the actors and lack of plot that killed it. I think it threw together too many of the books into one story, plus for a movie that cost THAT much, I would have hoped for a few bigger names involved. I actually quite liked their take on the aliens, but i just felt it was too short with characters but also felt unnaturally long...i wanted to bail about 30 minutes before the end!
Real shame as the original books were great and i think it could have been a great movie. and yes the title is LAME, it sounds like an oscar winning biopic starring Tom Hanks or something!
I worked on this for about 6 months doing some matte painting towards the end of the project. For the people who think the CGI was at fault here, take a close look. I had the opportunity to frame-by-frame through some of the shots of the Tharks, and they really were breathtakingly good. I did some comparisons with Avatar which is still kind of held as the height of CG characters, and the only real difference is design, not the quality of the CG. I think the design of the tharks was great, but would just have worked better as a feature animation rather than live-action movie.
In the end i enjoyed the movie to a point. Its a 3/5 film really. Its true that JCOM came well before Star Wars, Avatar etc but because those movies did come first this felt oddly derivative...
The bleached desert look ended up just feeling a bit bland, which frazettas illustrations certainly never did! Also, a character that can jump half a mile thru the air will always look wrong, its just not natural...
Its not Stanton's best film by any stretch, but I still had a fun couple of hours watching it.
This is what I was hoping for:
Minimal art went nowhere. - Sol LeWitt
I browsed trough a couple of nearby libraries yesterday and didn´t found any of the books, not even in the english editions sections (though i did find a song of ice and fire books in english at a superb price and got the first two) Goes to show how far below the radar this thing went, i usually see in the main shelve any book that gets adapted to a tv show or movie. even way before it premiers.
What probably killed the movie in the box office wasnt the quality or the plot, but more notably the marketing or lack off better put, it was very weak and very scarce, if they have gone for the same publicity weight Pirates of the Caribbean had they may have made POtC amount of dollars in the opening weekend.
And its sad, because not only could mean the end of John Carter´s movie saga, but can also mean that other projects Disney is uncertain about in monetary terms would get trown far to the back or be put an extra ton of pressure and less support in favor of another decade of nothing but profitable preteens singing musicals. Studios can do with bad reviews, but box office numbers weight a ton more in the decision making.
Like i said i didn´t read the books or was familiar with the story, when i first saw a billboard and i read John Carter against a black background i though it was some accountants biography picture. Would have also made sense since it was a small add on an area thats not too out there, like any low budget film, certainly not a Disney produced fantasy adventure blockbuster
"John Carter , the motion picture about the texan accountant who revolutionize the book keeping methodology in the late 50s and had a fairly uneventul average life otherwise."
I just got home from the movie and it's..really good!
I loved the ending *0* The cg was great!
I would totally buy this movie when it comes out in Blu-ray and re-watch it in French like I always do with every movie I really like.
It has got to be the marketing where they failed. I remember seeing the poster on the subway and going "John who?" and then looking at the alien riding the monster and going "the hell is going on here?" :V
To Slothboy: Ray Harryhausen had a take on John Carter of Mars? That would have been just as interesting as Bob Clampett's hand-drawn demo.
The Louisianian Sketchbook You can Comment and Criticize if you want.
My Newgrounds Profile Warning: Politically Incorrect thoughts, view at your own risk.
My Facebook Site I stopped using it years ago.
Louisianian artists thread If you're from or live in Louisiana, don't hesitate to post here.
My Profile Nothing else needs to be said.
Trillian: Zenithian Oh, and I am also a GNASH supporter/promoter.
Nintendo Network ID: FightingSeraph
I favorite scene must be when John Carter first saw the Dejas on the flying craft and all of sudden decide to kill all those people to save her.
"What the F? I'm on Mars, the world has gone crazy and I'm captured by weird aliens.
OMG!!! There's a woman with big BOOOBS in the sky, I 'm gonna jump into the air and kill people and save her!!""
Well, apparently that's the most natural thing to do.
Or they holding a wedding with all those bloody corpses around them. Yep, the first thing I would do after killing all those people xD
we've all done it
sb most art copied to page 1
Weapons of Mass Creation 2011 ::: Add your favourites!
facebook: Alface Killah
Developed Actively by the makers of the Best Amazon Podcast