I had some friends that really hated it whenever they saw work that looked like anime. I personally love it when it's done right since I'm an anime fan myself but I can understand the hatred from all the bad fanart on deviantart. I really love http://www.jasonchanart.com/ and his work has an anime influence. I'm just wondering what everyone's opinions are because my style is sort of realistic but I put a lot of anime traits in like the big eyes and bright colored hair.
I do whatever I think is necessary to get my point across. Classic line, ink and brush, hard-edge, manga/anime influence, abstraction where appropriate, fingerpainting, block printing, typography, a baseball bat on a pile of glass. You (meant in general) don't like it, fuck you. Just don't tell me I'm doing it wrong, or I'll hurt you...real bad...
Last edited by Ilaekae; June 7th, 2008 at 05:05 PM.
No position or belief, whether religious, political or social, is valid if one has to lie to support it.--Alj Mary
Ironically, the concept of SIMPLICITY is most often misunderstood by simple-minded people. --Alj Mary
With the right knowledge, it is the same with any other style and, like other styles, can look amazing. Jason Chan is one of those people who can do it very well. It would be very hard to hate on him simply because his art is Anime-influenced.
Just so you know, I was one of those DA guys who would draw horribly done Anime pieces without the knowledge of the basic foundations of art and design . I did it because I liked to do it, and I still like the style enough to incorporate some of the elements into my works. There is nothing wrong with that. That's not to say I'm close to Jason Chan's level, but I'm learnin'.
There's good in every style of art. On the other hand though, there's also a lot of bad examples. I know of many "anime" style artists, and indeed they are excellent at what they do. However, they also show an appreciation for many of the basic fundamental skills in art.
I think you need to get a strong foundation in drawing from life no matter what type of art you like or have a preference for. Every year I end up with one or more students who are only interested in drawing anime and manga. I like to break them of that habit but it's not easy. The ones who've taken my advice and been willing to go back to basics are the ones whose work tends to grow while those that won't listen or try something out of their comfort zone tend to stagnate and in some cases lose interest all together. It sounds harsh but it helps to pinpoint the ones who really have the potential to get to the next level.
I don't think he's trying to "beat" him... They're two totally different people with two totally different digs.
^Well, people may find it rude.
Its not anime influence. Its Eastern influence.
Anything in any style if done ameuture will be poor. If you pursue the eastern style, then pursue it. Focus on making your own style. Learn all the foundation in art and practice them, use them. When the Japanese got the anatomy text from the west they applied it to their art.
I'm not sure if I can say if Jason Chans concept work is has the Eastern influence. Limha Lekan, Falcoon, Gezstar, James Jean ect. Yes.
If you like to do it. Don't let your friends comments stop you. But remember you'll get hired based specifically upon your style. Unless your Jo chen and you versitile.
Last edited by Micaiah Nelson; June 8th, 2008 at 12:15 AM.
ive been into anime since.
i dont mind it, or peoples styles influenced by it. but i get tired of that very stereotypical style of anime that seems to be sweeping the world and younger artist.
this very pokemon, inuyashaish style of anime with triangled faced small pointy noses and huge eyes.
i dont care what an individuals style looks like. but people are just copying what they see and they arnt developing style. which is leading to tons of copies.
It's just a style, like every other style out there, there are those that hate it or love it or just don't understand it.
It all comes down to enjoyment and how much you relish your work which is done in that style.
Of course though, in all footnote of doing art, one must understand basics of anatomy, structure and perspective and so on.. so thats where the hate for manga/anime comes from, those people whom keeps drawing in that style without the proper basics.
furry is another story.
Micaiah, I think you're oversimplifying a bit there. (Or I just missed your point somehow.)
I do not agree. That's like limiting the term "western influence" only to "impressionistic influence".There's more to eastern art than just anime. (Look here: http://www.startdrawing.org)Its not anime influence. Its Eastern influence.
Japanese knew anatomy just as well as the western artists. There are pretty ancient anatomy books in existence.When the Japanese got the anatomy text from the west they applied it to their art.
Even that can be done well, imaginative and interesting. It's more of a genre than a style, though - different story.furry is another story.
I, for one, still can't pin-point what I don't like about alot of anime, despite trying real hard (not just the badly done ones; there's something about the style itself that makes it look unappealing to some people). I really do enjoy recent "rought" eastern animation styles, like the one Studio 4°C has going (Tekkonkinkreet, Mind Game), or the part-naturalistic anime in illustration.
When it comes to concept art - anime is a style. If it fits a project well, why not?
Where not talking about animation or comics but the style itself. Some artist are not from Japan. nor do comics or animation. They have a different term for both in China and Korea! You can call it Chinese influence and use all the reds you want. Just don't say anime. Plus there was a shift in the style as soon as they got the the Anatomy Text from the Western artist through imports.Although the term is used in Japan to refer to animation in general, in English usage the term most popularly refers to material originating from Japan, a subset of animation.
What was that link for?
Last edited by Micaiah Nelson; June 8th, 2008 at 10:42 AM.
my problem is that a lot of people starting off drawing these days seem to draw anime rather than try and develop their own style, no problem with anime personally but I think its more important to be able to develop your own style rather than merely ape a particular style, and understand that anime is an stylised art form and it is important to understand basic fundamentals such as anatomy etc.
you need to understand the rules before you can bend them.
"There aren't any shortcuts. You've got to dig in – study and draw the world around you. This is the only way to hone your skill and develop a style that is your own". GREG CAPULLO
I'll say this though, most of the folks who don't like manga/anime style art usually can't draw it themselves. It's so "simple" that they can't figure it out, so they call it "stupid." And folks complaining about style kinda seem to forget that everybody gets influenced by some artist and tries to draw like that artist. It's just that nobody thinks copying Frazetta makes you lame, just copying Otomo Katsuhiro.
Anime bothers me for 1 reason alone: it is intending on representing humans. And clearly, there is nothing human about eye balls that take up more mass inside the skull then the brain itself.
I think this keeps me from enjoying anime, and keeps me from respecting it as much as I do western style cartoonin. In western cartoons, when the "toon" aspect is introduced there is a pretty clear distinction between reality and cartoon (I'm thinking of Elmer Fud), but anime is so close to realism, that these obvious and intended imperfects drive me crazy.
Perhaps I think it through too much but... I am not a fan of anime influencing western art. Asian art is one thing, but those goddamn huge eyeballs are another.
My work: [link]
Maybe people hate it because of the story cliches, stuff like Pokemon are pretty much responsible for this stigma.
I hate anime/manga that uses a lot of cheap tricks to avoid drawing good action scene and expressive posture ().
Unlike, say, spiderman where you can't really see the facial expression of the hero but it still can conveys a lot of mood from everything else.
Last edited by enrigo; June 9th, 2008 at 05:20 PM.
I can understand why there are people that can't find the appeal in it, since it's more of an expressional way of drawing then it's realistic and so the face is made in a very expressional way and the body as well to show emotions clearly. That's how I see it, it's even there from the old japanese paintings that have that way of freely expression against the old european perfect realistic way of painting. It's just a cultural matter I guess.
But it's just like everything else: it's just a style and just a matter of preference. But I guess a lot of the anime/manga hate and trashing of artists inspired by anime/manga has to do with not liking anything unfamiliar.
What I enjoy about Anime is not only the style of art the style of story telling. What I find interesting is that people hate on Anime/Manga style so much, but there are many, many, many American cartoons that are also highly stylized and yet you probably won't get much hate if you are drawing them instead of Japanese counterparts.
It's also pretty funny when really good artists try to mimic anime "here's my attempt to create an anime piece" and it's just a realistic girl with large breasts and pink hair with slightly oversized eyes. THAT'S NOT ANIME. In most cases the eyes in anime are proportionate to the size and shape of the head. Anyway, Anime isn't about differences in the size or color of body parts, it's an entire style of drawing that goes down the the very lines and gestures of the drawing.
There are actually many Anime, and Manga that are very realistically drawn with characters that are not highly stylized with large eyes or extra long limbs, and no characters in the story have wild hair styles... and it's still Anime/Manga, and you can tell the difference just by looking at them. However people that criticize and hate on Anime only seem to see pink haired (or blue haired) girls with large breasts and huge blue eyes. I think they just see what they want to see, and no matter how legitimate the style is they are always going to consider it a lower form of art, even after it finishes taking over the world and influencing every thing in it.
What always fascinated me about Anime-style drawings is the way they are drawn down to the very basic level. It was much more interesting than what I was seeing in American comics at the time and light years ahead of what I was seeing in American Animation at the time. Now for me, it's all about the story. People in Japanese cartoons die, kill each other, have real problems, do drugs, smoke, and are still drawn really awesome... but then this thread isn't really about the differences in American vs Japanese Animation.
In the end people are going to draw what they like to draw, if people are getting interested in art, I don't see what the problem is. If they actually go on to pursue an education in Art I think they have a good shot at becoming a good artist. I think it's mostly non-artists that have the problem with the style because they see it everywhere, doesn't help that a lot of the imported Anime on TV (at least in the US) isn't always the best Anime *cough*Narutard*cough*.
A: Because everybody knows that white is the default race.
To me it's fine. Concept art is not just personal style and it couldn't exist without computer games or movies. If they are making computer game with some anime flavor in it and art director wants that then somebody has to paint it .
Just like Samurai_em in anime I mostly enjoy storytelling. When there is amazing plot, I don't pay so much attention to drawing style.
Look at all amazing professional concept art on this forum. I wouldn't call it non creative. You can put your imagination into costumes, design, mood, narration and many other things. Besides, realistic art can be also slightly stylised and usually is. It's not something stiff.My problem with realism is that it's not really all that imaginative or creative. The focus is only on making things look real, not actually coming up with something interesting, different or new.
All I'm saying is most of the comments here on CA about manga/anime are just to trash and bash different styles and artists that realistic artists either don't like or can figure out. That's really great basically say someone sucks because they'd rather draw stylized samurai or girls with pink hair over painting some guy staring out at an airship in a mountain range or cyborg with a dozen eyes and missing half her face. And it's just genius to act like everyone who draws or paints realistically is a pro, but anyone doing stylized work hasn't got an ounce of skill.
You ain't got to like the style, but you do have to diss it or the artists who use it either.
Where do you see hate in this thread?But reading this thread and looking at a lot of the manga/anime hate here it kinda seems like the only way to do that is make sure everything looks real.
People on CA like different styles but usually those that show some result of artistic growth/evolution behind artist. Realistic art is just the best foundation from which you can grow and branch out.
Last edited by Farvus; June 13th, 2008 at 07:11 PM.
The imaginativeness is probably not so much an issue here that turns people off from manga. Surely there is a lot of fantasy fiction or stylized art that feels totally derivative out there.
I think that the best example of a good manga that still retains a lot of the stylized look is Death Note. Even the feet and toes were drawn with so much character and expressiveness in it that I can't keep my eyes away from it.
I think anime is a perfectly acceptable style (if not a little unoriginal). In fact, I like it... when its done by professionals.
part of the stigma attached to anime comes from all the terrible imitations that an upcoming generation of teens/kids are producing. These guys are the generation that grew up on Pokemon/Digimon/YuGiOhMy/Dragonball/Naruto.
Anime and Manga have inspired a lot of people to get into art when they normally wouldn't. This is good and bad. good cuz art is fun. bad because there are now a lot of untalented artists who make crappy looking anime.
You can see these people on DeviantArt.