Results 1 to 13 of 21
May 28th, 2008 #1
help a young artist with his art.
this not yet finished, however i want it to look professional when im done, im using corel painter for this.
its meant to be a gladiator type character any crit would helpful. especially on colour and tone. and anything else that will make him look cooler.
Hide this ad by registering as a memberMay 28th, 2008 #2
Hello. I like this piece but
May 28th, 2008 #3
I think this needs to be altered slightly. First off, I personally find painting onto a white surface daunting, Try blocking in a bit of colour to destroy the white. The sword resting on the gladiators shoulders isn't actually on his shoulders, drop it down a bit. And I would recommend using a harder brush to lay in large sections of colour, then get in about it with finer brush and get the details in. Please post it when you decide its finished as it is a good piece that deserves attention! Seeya.
May 28th, 2008 #4
I think the sword should be angled into the background - to me it looks like he's trying to shave the back of his neck. I feel that I should be able to see more of his legs between the robe. Right now I can't tell where the legs connect to the hip. I like his chest and his arms.
May 28th, 2008 #5
May 28th, 2008 #6
May 29th, 2008 #7
May 29th, 2008 #8
Lower the sword, add a face and render till completion. Then see whats needed.
May 29th, 2008 #9
You know why everything is looking really light and almost as if it's a crayon drawing (not talking about he quality, just the lightness of it) it' because you did this straight onto a white BG.
Use a toned background of some sort to start off. It's a lot easier to judge value when you're starting off with something that isn't blindingly bright or extremely dark.
May 30th, 2008 #10
I'll post this in your sketchbook and the critique centre so you can't miss it.
Okay, well, I'll give you some of the major tips that have helped me with getting to grips with digital painting. What I'd do is go in with some more solid shapes and don be afraid to go over your original lineart. I like to do a loose sketch then block in the silloute with values, it will make it so much easier to see the form of the character and alter the pose quickly.
The first one is, kill all the white on a page. If its gonna be a rendered character on a white background then get rid of all the white on all the spaces you plan on rendering. At the moment all the colours look a little washed out because some of the white is still visible through the colours. What I'd do, is take some kind of midtone for each main colour/value are and block it in with an opaque brush to give it a more solid feel. Then, you can start adding shadows and highlights to sculpt out the form.
.................................................. .................................................. ...
As for the anatomy and pose, I'd like to give you a detaile paintover, but unfortunately my laptop has gone in for repairs.. so I'm gonna have to try and explain it in words. I'll give you a list of easy changes that will help this piece out. If it seems like I'm being harsh, well, maybe its because I am, but I hope you can get something useful out of this post.
1. The upper arm of his right arm, holding the sword is too squished together. If you put your arm in that position, as if holding a sword, it is more comfortable to have your forearm leaning back towards you. rather than away. Have his elbow thrust further out from the hand and his forearm leaning back in, that means you can stretch the upper arm outmore and have the muscles better defined, this pic kind of explains what I'm going on about, just imagine the angle of the arm slightly less steep and the hand grasping the sword.
2. As a whole, he looks too short for a typical hero figure, unless he's meant to be a dwarf or something. Typically, the legs need to be quite a bit longer, the halfway mark in the body is the groin, not the hips like in yours. Make his thighs and lower legs longer, and make sure the thighs are longer than the lower legs. this mark djurdjevic pi gives you a good idea of muscely hero proportions...also its totally badass.
3. The biggest problem for the piece as a whole is that it looks flat, if you desaturate the whole picture you will notice that everything is sort of light greys, even the areas in shadow. Coloured pieces will never look right if the values aren't right. To help this piece I would just desaturate it (make it black and white, if you are working in photoshop just press ctrl+shift+u), then work from there, colours are hard to get right at first and its a good idea to learn to get your values right first. Then I'd give the entire piece a grey tone and work from there. Greyscale is a much better way to learn to paint as a begginer.
4. Some things that should be symmetrical, like the helmet, aren't. Always flip your piece horizontal every ten minutes or so, the mistakes will jump out to you more obviously. It helps to keep correcting things. Also don't be too precious about anything, if you render something for an hour, then realise its completely wrong, you just gotta re-do it. Its no use getting too attatched.
5. The chest and stomach anatomy is a little funny
ignoring the text, this could be a useful reference for the chest and stomach anatomy
Never fret to use references anyone who tells you its cheating, well, doesnt know what they are talking about.
6. No face? an obvious one, but you can't keep delaying it. Every good piece needs a focal point, and in character art, more often that not its the face, or the eyes. Your eye needs an area of detail it can come back to and rest on, without a face, we remain uninterested and just move on. If you are struggling with it just use reference as well.
7. establish a light source. You don't want to just have that camera flash look, figure out where the light is coming from and block in areas of shadow and light. Also, remember to think about bounced light of shiny or reflective surfaces and learn how to render different materials differently. There are some useful links on the forum for that kind of thing but nothing works better than learning through observation. Do lots of life drawing of different objects and build up a good visual library.
8. costume design. Think about what kind of era's look are you aiming for. Research a topic and look for references, if you wanna add your own spin on it thats good. Just remember, all the best fantasy has some kind of grounding in reality.
For now, that covers some of the more obvious things but you can still think about little details like, how is that sword resting on his shoulders? and why that helmet digs into his neck? Of course there is the obvious keep studying anatomy but it would be stupid on my part to presume you don't already know that. www.characterdesign.com has some great full body poses under the photoset section. Some nude and some with cool costumes and props.
All in all keep on working on it, try to take some of the points I've raised into mind and don't forget to enjoy the process Keep on posting us with updates dude.
May 30th, 2008 #11
Miles_- thnx again
i changed a whole lot after hearing wat u said miles, and i think the image is alot better for it, u were right i was attached to the old image but now i see it for wat it really is.
im working of the proportion and anatomy first then i will move onto the face, then the rendering and other stuff. but i think the shape and form is important for now.
May 30th, 2008 #12
No problem man, one real quick thing that would really give this dude some cool heroic proportions, would be to have his hips thinner than the shoulders, check out that link I gave to the body building pics for a better idea. Its really nice to see you like the advice, its lookin better already.coming along nicely. I was meant to be doing some english essay or some other crap like that, and then I got a bit caught up and carried away givin you some crits. cya around man
May 31st, 2008 #13
been working on the legs which was difficult, and i found out his left are was too smal so i am changing it, im stll worried about the face but i know i have to work on it soon. i still feel the whole image is alittle skewd, but even after flipin it im not too sure how to fix it.
i wanna learn alot from this piece so i will finish it no matter how long it takes, but i think my next update will be monday since i got to do some school work for monday.