Results 1 to 13 of 19
Thread: The Cintiq 12wx and the Modbook
February 9th, 2008 #1
The Cintiq 12wx and the Modbook
The new, smaller Cintiq is a really good idea and I love the format, but they didn't follow through and make it usable. I got one at work and it picks up RF interference like crazy. Worse than my old Graphire tablet, and that thing would get interference from radio signals and cell phones. So after a couple weeks working with the IT guys and separating out all my cords and trying different locations, we ended up calling Wacom, and they basically told us that the 12wx isn't shielded as well at the other Cintiqs and is not intended for serious workstation use. It's not just one faulty monitor, it's the whole model. The IT guys are attempting to rig it with some kind of aftermarket shielding, but it's probably not going to work and we'll have to return it for one of the bigger ones.
If anyone out there is considering this great-looking, smaller, cheaper, more portable tablet monitor... Keep saving up and get a big Cintiq instead.
I also have a Modbook - and aside from some huge problems with OSX which I think are my fault, the feel of that thing is great. It's got 512 levels of pressure sensitivity, and the surface of the glass actually felt nicer than that of the Cintiq... And no interference at all... And it's a self-contained computer, which gives it points over the Cintiq, and has all the usual Macbook ports *and* an optical drive, the only slate tablet that has that. People have asked me about lag, and honestly it seems like the only times I've noticed any lag at all were in the write-anywhere handwriting recognition (just a pause between starting to write and having the little balloon for your writing pop up) and a little in Photoshop - and they seemed to be software issues. The lag when drawing a line in Photoshop was the same as doing so on an Intuos.
There was a bit of getting-used-to with it, especially being a PC person, and at first I found the thing totally frustrating (mostly the lack of a keyboard, but it's got USB ports for that). But as far as a direct digital drawing surface (tried the Fujitsu Stylistic a bit too) I haven't found anything that really matches it. Plus it's not Vista... I really wanted a tablet laptop but not Vista so it's really the only option now that Vista's on all new Windows laptops.
So anyone out there looking for a direct drawing surface... Just some personal experiences to help you make your choice.
Hide this ad by registering as a member
February 23rd, 2008 #2Registered User
- Join Date
- Sep 2003
- Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
I'm really considering the modbook... but I'm not sure I want to give up PC stuff altogether (not too mention all my software is PC version). Have you tried running windows on the modbook? I'm not exactly sure how it works, but apparently you can have several OS's on the new macs. Just wondering if and how it works?
February 23rd, 2008 #3
This got posted on another forum of mine: http://www.xernon.co.uk/products/xpc1700b.html
Its a cheaper non-wacom cintiq. None of us know if its any good, but its certainly a good bit less expensive. I'd bet its quite usable.
EDIT: try this link. I think the old one got moved on their website: http://www.p-active.eu/uk/products/xpc1700b.html
Last edited by aesir; March 5th, 2008 at 12:30 AM.
February 23rd, 2008 #4
February 24th, 2008 #5
Thanks for the info man, I have been thinking about getting a cintiq12 for a while, for its portability..Id have to reconsider now. When you get interference on it, what exactly happens to it, how is it affected??
I use my cintiq on a daily basis, and I have gotten some interference from my speakers, but it only jiggles my cursor at the edge of the screen...no biggie.
if the interference is greater than that, then Id have to pass on it.
On the other hand, that xernon screen is looking pretty sweet...I looked around their site and I did not see any US shipping or services.
Anyone know if they sell to the US? Id be happy to try one out and review it...take one for the team..hehe
"Be who you are and say what you feel,because those that mind don't matter and those that matter don't mind."-Dr. Seuss
February 24th, 2008 #6
I've already got a saving account dedicated to getting a mod book, as a mac user I could care less about the PC end but it would be cool to be able to use everything possible. At the moment I have a fairly new imac and I use the PC side for games mostly. The mod book looks so juicy.
My work: [link]
February 24th, 2008 #7
lol yea alfaro, plz buy that xernon and tell us all if its worth it.
February 24th, 2008 #8
the Modbook looks well impressive....they should call it a WacBook.......
(now, if they can just merge Painter with Photoshop....)
February 24th, 2008 #9
Seeker - I know you can install Vista on the Modbook. They had two demo models running on Vista at MacWorld. YOu might even be able to buy them with Vista installed instead of OSX, I'm not too sure. I've actually been having issues transitioning to OSX myself, and I still haven't gotten Mac versions of all the software I like to have. But I head such terrible things about Vista that I didn't want to get any new computer with that OS installed.
Blue - I'm a she
So yeah, it might be okay without an additional monitor, but it's kind of too small to be a primary monitor. But if you want a cheaper Cintiq and are okay with a small screen then maybe it's not so bad.
I've gone back to a dual monitor with an Intuos at work until the IT crew sorts this out. They're attempting to shield it themselves but they're swamped so I have to wait -_-
Edit: That Xernon thing looks pretty cool... No expresskeys or touchstrip but I find myself using the keyboard instead anyway so that wouldn't bug me... If anyone tries it out, let's hear how it goes!
Last edited by nonie; February 24th, 2008 at 03:33 PM.
February 24th, 2008 #10
A couple of months ago I saw someone working with that laptop with a real Wacom build in the screen, 512 levels of pressure sensitivity etc. that you could turn and pivot, so you actually had a keyboard like a normal laptop in addition to the screen. I can't remember the name or type number of it though, but the Modbook resembles it a bit. Not sure if it's still being produced or sold either
February 24th, 2008 #11LOOPY
- Join Date
- Sep 2007
- Thanked 87 Times in 54 Posts
February 25th, 2008 #12Registered User
- Join Date
- May 2005
- Thanked 94 Times in 38 Posts
Nonie, I'm sure your problem is an isolated one. I have a Cintiq 12WX as part of a 3 monitor setup, with two big speakers nearby and there is no interference on mine. The very edges are jittery but that is a problem common to all cintiqs and tablet PCs, the center is absolutely fine.
February 25th, 2008 #13
serhc - Noope, no keyboard, but the Modbook has a little remote that looks like an ipod that you can program keystrokes to. It won't do modifiers like shift or alt, which is annoying. But it does have a USB input so I'm going to get one of those Matias folding keyboards when they come out and use that.