need a suggestion

[bennykapelli]

Hello.
I need a suggestion about my sketch. Tonight i changed the drawing from my first idea, but a workmate told me that he preferred the original version (with the man).

which one do you like?


http://bennykapelli.interfree.it/Pictures/Horse.JPG

...and... take a look at this picture (wip)

http://bennykapelli.interfree.it/Pictures/Benny1.JPG

Thank you
Bye

[metalwinds]

i agree with your workmate, the original is stronger. the big monster guy doesnt seem to fit in with the subject matter, and he makes the composition weaker.

[Mindflaw]

I agree with metalwinds, the original is better. I think the crossing diagonals gets a little disrupted by the monsters size, anyhow the original is much better, more feeling in it

[behemot5]

i sincerely prefer the one on the left.........

[mushuhaha]

The guy.