Ashenguard region (map)

[r3t]

This is a map some canadian guy requested me to make for an online RPG game he is developing.
He was very glad with the result, how do you people feel about it?

http://lotrmaps.middle-earth.us/1/2.jpg

... sorry about the size and dimentions.

[mathes]

The terrain is nice, you can easily see the slopes, ranging from small hills to vast mountains. The only thing that bothered me was that the points of interest were perfect copies of one another, especially the dragon caves.

But otherwise, nice work.

[soupface]

it has a clean, friendly look to it.

while the temples and camps look like they're part of the map (roughly), the orc towers seem to be drawn in straight profile. they don't fit the style of the others, in my opinion (and don't cast shadows on the terrain like the others do).

i'm overly critical. looks nice, like it was shaped out of something (plasticine?) and not painted (esp. the grasses and the water). some of the mountains look like objects hidden under some sort of gray cloth.

[Yaseck]

My only crit is "mountains". I don't know... Looks kinda plastic to me. Maybe some texture on it?