Bammer vs. Toaster POLL Round 2 - CHAINSAWS!

[wassermelone]

Well its a little later than the sunday, but Greg was at a con in Tampa the weekend so its all cool. This weeks battle was chainsaws!

Bammer's piece
http://webspace.ringling.edu/~gbahm/ghostsAloneInPairs.jpg

Toaster's piece
http://www.rsad.edu/~awhitmor/images/chainsawfinal.jpg

Vote away!

(Sorry, forgot to put a poll in the other thread.)


*edit
Please also comment/critique.

[vigostar]

shit... these are both very good.. at first I was like wow.. toaster has this hands down but, after analyzing bammers im not so sure.. i really like bammer stlyzed version.... Good going to both... My votes going to Bammer,.,.!

[juicy_fruit]

wow really amazing.. if i was going for chainsaw battles i would go for bammer then again if it was posing with a chainsaw i would go you toaster.. im not sure wether the topic is battle or just has to do with chainsaws i really like the colours in bammers with the giant chainsaw swords.. im going bammer great job!

oh and i live in clearwater! so tampa isnt that far away :yayca:

[Eric Drobile]

Toasty has ruled my face with his HEV suit wearin chainsaw babe.

[Bammer]

Wow it's neck and neck. How exciting.

[emperor_boy]

Drew, I dunno. There's nothing really wrong with it, I guess, I'm just

-not really a fan of the scratchy style (too visually confusing for a tasteless clod like myself)
-not getting an emotional reading off of the situation that I gather (from context) is supposed to be dramatic. It's very stiff.
-thinking that the colors used might just be a tad *too* dark.

Or maybe I'm nuts. I dunno.

Greg:

Like I've said, it's much better than the first one you did. I still think you could have done better, but that would be like expecting everybody to draw a perfect picture, every single time. My only real complaints are about the lack of expression on the face of the visible character's face, and the fact that while this image is obviously supposed to be "dynamic", the pose of the character closest to the viewer seems static. I think I already said that at soem point, yes? Oh well. I typed it again so I wouldn't look like I was just being a dick to Drew.

[Idiot Apathy]

Hmmm, toaster has style, bammer has style and composition...

Decisions, decisions...



Bammer, but the toaster's armor is so nice... but the head is cut off... annoying.. Bammer with the gorgeous colors... aieeeee!

[dns2k]

looks like i tied it up... bammer i love the style
toaster- you got my vote man very well done

-dns

[Athey]

Bammer's piece is really dynamic and fluid. It's a great action shot and the composition is really well thought out. I like it the best of the two.

[REEF]

I like the motion in Bammer's piece

[Blahm]

the long chainsaws are cool. like special fighting chansaws.

[Danilo]

bammer, even toaster has tasty chainsaw. Also bouth of you have cut off the acters head.