View Full Version : Teen Challenge 116: Spirit Animal - Voting
April 17th, 2011, 07:32 PM
Teen Challenge 116: Spirit Animal
Voting for the Teen Challenge 116: Spirit Animals (http://conceptart.org/forums/showthread.php?t=218640)
April 17th, 2011, 07:57 PM
ah what!!??? i thought we still had another 2 hours till the deadline! :(
I need to figure out the whole timezone thing...
April 17th, 2011, 10:55 PM
lancer - bookmark this shit (http://wwp.greenwichmeantime.com/)
April 18th, 2011, 02:16 AM
haha ryanoir, i just googled that before i saw your post. figured that out so it shouldnt be a problem from now on.
tempest-haze: your colors and atmosphere are really great and i like the overall mood of the piece. for me though, the brief isnt very apparent from the image. the lion does have that shiny glowy-ness which suggests it could be more than some regular lion, but its only that: suggested. there also isnt much connection between the warrior and the lion. he could have just stumbled upon it, he could be about to fight it; we dont know. make their connection more obvious. other than that, good job :)
Ludic: I can definitely see some improvement from your earlier stuff :) same thing i said to tempest-haze though: make the connection b/w guy and spirit animal more obvious. the composition feels a little cramped as well; i think you can take out one of the guys in the foreground. also, the values on the eagle are looking a little flat. i dont think you were really bothering with color on this one so i wont say much, but just watch out for using all the same hues. switch it up with warmer/cooler and sifferent levels of saturation. nice work
zelda_geek: nice colors as usual :) not much to crit with this one other than i think the kid coud be a little lighter overall to show a wee bit more detail. the piece also has a lot of movement and i think it would be good to have played with having the view be much closer to the boy and have him take up more space in the composition. as of right now the composition is kinda static. cool piece though!
The Pariano: I like how this turned out. i think the dude in he front could have been more resolved though. i understand that hes not the focus, but since hes so close to the viewer it would be good to detail him a bit more, even if youre going to blur him out later.
Sulpher: hahaha i like this. good sense of scale and nice colors :) its just not reading as "spirit" to me though. it just looks like a giant walrus. you probably didnt want to g th obvious glowy animal route, but i think you should have something showing its not just a giant, toothy walrus; like glowing eyes or something. awesome stuff :)
voted for The Pariano's cuz i think it fits the most with the brief
well, heres what i did. still kinda bummed i missed the deadline :/ oh well, learned my lesson for next time. im pretty happy with it but theres still a lot of things i need to improve on. like hands and feet and drapery and -- ill stop there, haha. anyway, till next time guys!
April 19th, 2011, 07:25 AM
lancer_idenoure: Thanks for the crit! And sorry you missed the deadline. :( It would've definitely gotten my vote. Still, I'd like to offer you a crit in return, if you don't mind.
I like the overall composition of your piece, and the poses you chose for both the spirit and the person are tricky, but you pulled them off nicely. His hands, however, seems a bit "childlike" if you get what I mean? Also, his upper arm is too long in comparison to his forearm. Other than that, this piece was great (and I also like the lighting as well).
I have to get to class but more critiques later! :)
EDIT: Here we go:
Ludic: Awesome composition, but I feel you could've pushed the values a bit more. As is, the animal and the people look like silhouettes. Maybe also make it more apparent that the bird is a spirit?
zelda_geek: This was an overall great illustration. My only comment is that the boy's anatomy seems a bit off and looks to be lacking in detail when compared to the rest of the piece. Other than that, great work!
The Pariano: This was a favorite of mine. :D I really see nothing to point out, but I would have maybe spread the elements of your piece out. The composition feels a bit cramped.
Sulphur: haha this piece made me smile :) I agree with lancer_idenoure that the animal doesn't quite strike me as a "spirit." However, I have to give you credit for thinking outside the box. :)
April 23rd, 2011, 12:25 PM
Voted zelda_geek. Great composition and colours, nice work.
Also, LOL'd at the poll question. ;)
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.1 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.